Manual or Auto??

Anything non model specific but still BMW related goes here.
Post Reply
User avatar
Site Owner
Posts: 23460
Joined: 12 Oct 2011, 13:22
Car model: 135i M Sport
Isetta 300
Location: Bucks
Location: Buckinghamshire

Manual or Auto??

Post by M60NJP » 12 Feb 2018, 12:37

This has probably been discussed previously, but I was browsing Autotrader this morning and saw an E60 550i for sale............with a manual gearbox!! 'No way!' I thought, gotta be auto.........but then looked at other BMW models and realised there's no 'recipe' (in my mind!), for example:

All 7-series = Auto only
5-Series = Err........probably manual at 2.0l (approx) and auto in larger...........unless an E34 which should probably all be manual? (Anyone remember the 518i which was so slow it probably didn't matter...........)
3/4-Series and smaller = Total confusion! (E36/46/90), probably manual at 1.9/2.0l and auto above..........either in an M3...or maybe DCT.

Don't like diesels, so don't care!!

What are your prejudices/preferences in transmission?

User avatar
Matt N
BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 115
Joined: 17 Jul 2015, 20:05
Car model: E36 328i Individual
Location: Northamptonshire

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by Matt N » 12 Feb 2018, 18:37

Manual for me; I've had a few autos but would take a manual everytime given the choice. My E36 is an auto but I've got 95% of the parts to convert it, I just need to find the money for the last 5% and the time to actually get it done.

BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 1904
Joined: 01 Feb 2013, 19:32
Car model: E46 M3 Vert
E34 520i SE Touring
Porsche 944 2.7

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by theguvnor » 12 Feb 2018, 19:34

For me it comes down to the application. For 50k miles a year business Auto all day long. For fun, manual.

Nothing beats driving a manual E46 m3 at the weekend after spending the week slogging up and down the motorways of the UK. But nothing beats slogging up and down the motorways of the UK in an F10 520d auto!

Horses courses etc

User avatar
BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 2870
Joined: 10 Sep 2013, 12:40
Car model: E34-M5
E36-328 touring
E46-330d touring
Location: Bedfordshire

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by Discostew38 » 12 Feb 2018, 19:52

All depends on what you want from the car

I like autos and if I was looking at a big luxury car I would generally go auto
The E39 is a perfect example it's a mellow and relaxing car to drive as an auto
I would say only the bigger engines work well with automatic transmission

If I was after something sporty or a more involved driving experience it would be manual

The good things about the 550i is it can be both
A relaxing luxury car with the auto box
Sporty drivers car with the manual box

The other thing to consider is reliability
Automatic gearboxes are complicated and pron for expensive repairs
Manual gearboxes are pretty simple and generally don't go wrong so it's just clutch and flywheel

So if I was looking at an older car (as I do most of the time) I tend to go for a manual box

So with that said if I was looking at buying a 550i now it would be a manual
If you look at current prices on E39 540i or e36 328i or e46 330i you will see the manual cars cost more so better resale later in life
Life's to short to be driving boring cars
It's all about the old school

BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 5
Joined: 14 Feb 2018, 14:40
Car model: BMW 3 Series
Location: Yorkshire

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by TashaB » 19 Apr 2018, 11:36

Always auto for me!!!! For me personally its because I'm lazy!

User avatar
BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 11121
Joined: 17 Oct 2011, 14:24
Car model: '98 E36 323iSE Touring
'12 F31 330d Touring
Location: Reading, Berks.

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by Gus247 » 19 Apr 2018, 16:15

I was always a 'manual only' driver (despite the E36 being auto!) but recently having the F31 (330d, 8 speed auto, flappy paddles etc.) it's changed my view point quite dramatically. I still believe there is more fun to be had with a manual g/b but with the paddles and option to change manually, plus sport+ mode etc., the fun can still be had if required, but then sit on the motorway at (ahem) 70 with the cruise on....

as The Guvnor said, very much horses for courses. :)
aka Andy


BMW Forum UK

User avatar
Site Owner
Posts: 14219
Joined: 17 Oct 2011, 13:06
Car model: 1998 E36 M3 Convertible
Location: Essex

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by RayB » 19 Apr 2018, 16:56

Auto boxes have come along way really and if you were to take an M2 for example you just can't shift gears that quick anymore.

Personally I'd put it down to the age of the car. I certainly wouldn't want a 20 year old 5 series with an auto box but a brand new one would be fine.

User avatar
BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 9806
Joined: 26 Sep 2012, 16:27
Car model: bmw E36 saloon.
Location: Dorset.

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by cockneyrebel » 19 Apr 2018, 19:35

After years of driving in agony with a manual I'm now with the Auto gang, love it and wish I'd changed years ago,
Steptronics fun as well :-bd

BMW Enthusiast
Posts: 832
Joined: 14 May 2013, 23:35
Car model: 2003 E46 M3
2009 E60 520d
Location: Cambuslang, Scotland

Re: Manual or Auto??

Post by Ngy » 19 Apr 2018, 23:27

Commute from glasgow to cumbria f30 320d - auto

Weekends in the e46 m3 - manual

Each has a purpose and imo dont work (aswell) swapped about.

Post Reply

Return to “General BMW”